Himachal CPI(M) for CAG probe into government carton factory sale

Shimla: The Himachal unit of Communist Party of India (Marxist) has written to the Comptroller and Auditor General of India regarding sale of a public sector company making apple cartons having a worth of around Rs 30 crores to a private party for a paltry sum of Rs 1.08 crores.

Addressing a press conference here the CPI-M State Secretariat leaders Tikender Panwar and Dr Kuldip Tanwar disclosed
that the State government has sold the State PSU, Agro Industrial Packaging India Limited (AIPIL) to a scrap dealer of Nagpur against the wishes of thousands of apple growers and farmers in the hill State.

Giving the background of the factory the CPI-M said the AIPIL had imported and installed a state of the art machinery manufactured by Mitsubishi (Japan) and Simon Box Maker (U.K.) in 1990 to manufacture corrugated apple cartons as an alternative substitute to wooden boxes which were traditionally is use for packaging of Himachal apples.

The then State government conceived this project as a social business model in public sector to introduce and promote modern and green technology for the benefit of apple farmers not only in Himachal but in the entire apple belt of the country.

This PSU for years together had minimized the environmental degradation and had saved the forests besides creating employment opportunities to the local people. Now the government intends to start an ITI with public private participation.

It may be recalled that about a decade back when BJP government with same Chief Minister and Horticulture Minister were in power they had signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) in April, 2000 with a Maharashtra based Industrial House called Indage India to set up a Winery Project (with total processing capacity of 18,000 tonnes per year) at Pragati Nagar and valuable land worth several crore was given free of cost to this Industrial Group.

The project was even granted an excise exemption for 10 years to them while eluding the local farmers with a big publicity stunt of this kind.

Consequently Indage India has not set up any winery Unit till date on the allocated state land but has conspiringly grabbed 28 bighas of flat precious land free of cost which belongs to AIPIL factory.

The left party has said that in any case if the State government is interested in setting up an ITI on Public, Private Participation (PPP) business model then there is sufficient government land vacant available in the surrounding areas of the factory where ITI can be established .

The fact of the matter is that the concerned 28 bighas of land of the AIPIL constitutes as an industrial plot whose
Conversion Land Use (CLU) cannot be altered so blatantly since small and marginal farmers of the factory area sacrificed their collective land some 20 years ago to the State Government for setting up of AIPIL factory for socio-economic development purposes.

The CPI-M has stated that it clearly indicates that some vested interests are behind the shady deal to dispose off the valuable public asset and it is technically difficult to imagine that world class imported heavy duty machinery of AIPIL which has been sparingly used (average operating Plant and Machinery capacity achieved to the extent of 4 to 5 percent) for the past 20 years or so is now being considered and cleared as junk material to facilitate corrupt practices in public life.

Join the Conversation


  1. says: Rajneesh Sharma

    Dear Comrades,

    Very Sorry to INFORM you that the state which your party CPI has been ruling almost for three decades is INDIA’s worst debt prone state. If your policies and ideology was better then it should have shown demonstrated proof somewhere.

    just look into this http://news.in.msn.com/business/article.aspx?cp-documentid=4581086

    If CPI policies were so much for an ordinary man, or farmers, it wouldn’t have created a history in West Bengal where most suicides happened in past years.

    see on more proof —

    We all cry for Himachal issues, but no rescue, nothing happens, just few discussions and issues sleep in graveyards..as usual..If this system of loot and corruption is not checked within this country.. soon our leaders will create and leave a nation where even street dogs and monkeys too will become debt ridden and will be mortgaged to obtain loans from world bank..

    1. says: Ganesh

      Mr.Rajneesh Sharma,

      I am also very sorry to INFORM you that the government run by the Left parties, are administered under the Capitalist set-up that defined by the constition and the policies framed by the Central Government.

      1. says: Rajneesh Sharma

        Mr. Ganesh,

        Even I am also sorry to inform you, that while CPI shared power in center it couldn’t do anything except enjoying the media attention and intellectual discussions only. CPI could have toppled the government for justified issues.

        To blame center for every failure, its unjustified, there are many successful states where center and state governments are different. Gujrat is the biggest example and one of the most successful states in every manner.

        If this is the only excuse you give, i must say…its shallow. When you already know that nothing can be done with center – state tussle then whats fun in discussion Hi – Fi ideas that can never be implemented.

        Regarding capitalists set up.. What do you think would be the better option to feed crores of people in this country where governance at each level, be it village panchayat or any other department is run by mafia of corruption…

        Do you think that in West Bengal there is Satyuga or Ram Rajya at each step ?? and every unit of local governance functions smoothly…or there is no corruption at all? You also know.. thats not the case, in fact we all know just labels are different , be it Congress or BJP or CPI..every leader from any party has one mission – Loot Mission…!

        Morale of discussion – “Money and Corruption Are ruining the land, Crooked politicians Betray the working man, Pocketing the profits And treating us like sheep, And we’re tired of hearing promises.. That we know they’ll never keep”

Leave a comment
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.