Himalayan Ski Village project destroyed for wrong reasons – John Sims

Shimla: Environmental concerns, opposition by locals and politicians may have stalled the Himalayan Ski Village (HSV) project for a decade but promoter John Sims still hopes that it will see the light of day saying that the country’s largest FDI tourism project was ‘destroyed for the wrong reasons’.

In response to a Hill Post query, Sims, MD of HSV on email responded with, “The Himalayan Ski Village was accused of being an example for all that is wrong with Indian development today, environmental disregard, community/cultural destruction and government influence.”

He adds that “HSV was none of these things, in fact, it was actually the opposite, thus it was destroyed for the wrong reasons.

“It is example of the leaders of HP using the politics of negativity to further their own silly image at the expense of the people they claim to serve,” he said.


In response to Virbhadra Singh led congress government again showing interest in the multi-million dollar tourism project and backing it with withdrawing an opposing petition from the courts, Sims says, “Of course, we continue to hope the ski village will find a way forward, but this has to be judged on rational grounds and I suspect it will take us another six months to properly evaluate our options.”

Mentioning about taking the local community along on the project, he added, “but the BJP continues to threaten us with opposition. It seems they only support selective developers, who wish to do the same things we proposed; ropeway and hotels.”


Himalayan Ski Village Timeline

March 19, 2004: Himlayan Ski Village, a $ 350 million tourism project backed by Alfred Ford proposed.

The Himalayan Ski Village project proposes to construct 170 seven star rooms, 1000 four star rooms and 100 chalets on 93.1 hectares of land, of which 16.3 hectares was to be on government or forest lands near Palchan village of Manali.

Novermber 18, 2005; Himachal cabinet approves the HSV project

December 9, 2005; Memorandum of Understanding signed with Himachal Government.

February 2006: HSV project faces strong opposition in entire Kullu valley. A congregation of 164 deities (Kullu Devta’s) hold Jagti Pooch (assembly) to consider the HSV project and  overwhelmingly is rejected by the oracles present at the assembly of deities.

June 5, 2006: Implementation agreement signed.

June 25, 2007: Detailed project report of HSV approved

2007:  Two public interest litigations 892/2007 & 1237/2007 opposing the project filed before the Himachal High Court.

December 30, 2007; Congress government led by Virbhadra Singh loses the election and BJP led government under chief minister Prem Kumar Dhumal assumes office.

April 9, 2008 and April 30, 2008: The two PILs are disposed off. The government lets the court know that it was reexamining the HSV project. .

June 6; 2009: A public hearing at the project site was conducted by the principal secretary tourism at which those present openly rejected the proposal for the HSV project.

December 4, 2009: Based on the report of the principal secretary tourism, the Himachal government cabinet decides to serve a cancellation notice for the controversial project on the promoters.

April 2010: HSV moves HP High Court and obtains a stay on the government move to cancel the project.

June 22, 2012: HP High Court Judge quashes the government cancellation notice

August 2012: Himachal Government appeals before double bench of High Court

December 2012: Dhumal led BJP government loses power, Congress wins and elects Virbhadra Singh as chief minister.

May 2013: Congress government withdraws HSV case from HP High Court.

As Editor, Ravinder Makhaik leads a team of media professionals at Hill Post. Spanning a career of over two decades in mass communication, as a Documentary Filmmaker, TV journalist, Print Media journalist and with Online & Social Media, he brings with him a vast experience. He lives in Shimla.

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. says: Chhering

    It is highly unfortunate on part of us i.e. common people of Kullu valley that some unscrupulous political people for their own selfish motives misguided us and we whole heartily participated in the movement. Now everybody is repenting their decision to participate in that unfortunate movement after knowing the real facts and figures. Now common masses have realized that they have in fact done an irreparable damage to the tourism potential of Kullu valley by opposing Himalayan Ski Village. Implementation of HSV alone could have taken the tourism of our valley to an another league of tourist destinations not in India but in the whole world. HSV could have been our trump-card in case tourist once again start flocking to Srinagar. Moreover, keeping in view the greedy nature of people who are serving to the tourists in Manali area, it will not be far when even dogs will hate to come to our valley. But I still hope that there are a majority of people who will think of better future of Kullu-Manali and now they will start kicking away these so-called small time politicians from getting their long deserved rights.

Leave a comment
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.