I had penned articles under the same agonizing title in 2006, followed in 2007, in the spate of terrorist attacks by some wayward Muslim youth, who, totally misinterpreting Islam, took innocent lives either as murderers or as suicide bombers. Today, I think in the aftermath of the Tablighi Jamat Markaz at Bangleywali Masjid, spreading of the Coronavirus throughout India with its participants, going for the jugular of the same health workers who come to give them life, attacking the selfless police personnel and spitting on their faces, misbehaving with nurses by walking nude, urinating and defecating outside their rooms, lofting urine-filled bottles outside the windows in the isolation centers, as alleged, have all resulted in hanging my head in shame. In addition to that what more to be lamented is the fact that the community has been accusing the media for indulging in machinations to demonize Muslims .
In supplication to this is also the devilish creation of Tik-Toks, mocking at the Coronavirus, imploring Muslims not to wear masks maintain social distancing and carry on congregations in the mosques. The situation is far more ghastly as the terrorist attacks take lesser lives while the spread of the disease by the followers of Tablighi Jamat might be huge.
Perhaps, it seems to be a deliberate attempt to overlook and let down the state even in the wake of all the instructions of the Prime Minister and the government warning for the consequences of the Covid-19 pandemic and for maintaining social distancing and staying at home. These and many more people are also violating the golden mantra given by the Prime Minister, Narendra Modi — “Janata Curfew” (people’s curfew), “Lakshman Rekha” (following deadlines) and “Jaan hei to Janaan hei” (If there is life, everything can be done). In fact, the true “tabligh” should have been to get these three instructions be announced five times each day from the mosques.
The errant preaching of Maulana Saad catered to nothing in the name of God but misguiding his innocent and unassuming followers from all corners of the world. He knew well that he was doing it in the wake of the government clearly announcing on March 14, 16, 19 and 24 (twice by the Prime Minister Modi on March 19 and 24) for social distancing via lockdown.
The biggest disservice that Maulana Saad has done unto Muslims, is that he has incited his unassuming devotees against the State telling that the government has been trying to lock the mosques, besides it is creating divisions among Muslims by asking them to discontinue the congregations and that they avoid getting treated by non-Muslim doctors and that the best doctors would be from the Jamat only. It’s shocking that he has not spared even science and medicine besides telling them that it is better to die in mosques.
The Maulana has himself escaped under the guise of self-quarantine leaving in the lurch his faithful followers who have been running from pillar to post spreading the disease. Besides, carrying the albatross of the Coronavirus, they have been stigmatized by one and all. Wherever, the have lodged, they are refusing to get treated as Maulana Saad instructed them not to be treated by non-Muslims.
No one knows the brand of Islam that the Maulana Saab has been propagating that exactly seems Talibanized rather than being of Sufi nature, ultimately, providing the guilt edged opportunity to the Islam baiters. Certainly the brand of Islam taught by Maulana Saad is not what was the hallmark of Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) that was based on the teachings of the holy Quran and purely, the Sufi mannerisms to the extent that almost half of the world started following him. One fails to comprehend as to what kind of “tabligh” (preaching) these Tablighis propagating.
Frankly speaking, when one sees an exuberant religious head like Maulana Saad of the Markaz (other counterparts of his in other faiths being no lesser), enjoying an extremely secured and lavish lifestyle, I am reminded of the true Islamic fakirs and saints like Khwaja Hazrat Nizamuddin, Ameer Khusro and Hazrat Moinuddin Chishti, who used to fast in the day and prayed the whole night while breaking the fast with sookhi roti (dried bread) and plain water. What a huge difference in lifestyle.
Sadly enough, the value system, something that must never change even after 1400 years, if compared to the times of Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him), has presently rattled down to a bottomless hell among Muslims who are ready to take or sacrifice life for the Prophet (PBUH) but wouldn’t follow him in letter and spirit. God forbid, the Markaz Maulana, owing to his recalcitrant, stubborn and arrogant nature, could now be held responsible for 10,000 or more Coronavirus deaths, the way he kept on carrying on with his religious gatherings. Rather than coming in the open and asking all his Jamatis be treated by the doctors, who have gone into the hiding unnecessarily weighing on government and police’s resources in these times of crisis, like Nero, playing on his flute, he has disappeared into his ivory tower somewhere.
Despite an FIR against him for so many days, he hasn’t been traced, nor surrendered — something that he must have done on the first day. When he stated that he wasn’t afraid of anything, why has he escaped for the fear of getting arrested? The congregations continued till March 28 and it took an Ajit Doval, the National Security adviser to ask Saad Kandhlawi to get the premises vacated for fear of huge number of Covid-19 cases.
Muslims, already cajoled and beleaguered owing to being treated as the Congress vote bank for seven decades, have further been distancing themselves from the non-Muslims by aping their so-called belligerent leaders using inflammable language, like Asaduddin Owaisi, when he stated in an Anajna Omkashyap Aajtak debate, “
Such people have given a completely lopsided picture of Islam, otherwise a completely relaxed, full of accommodation and latest creed. People like Owaisi & Owaisi, Azam Khan, Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam, Shehla Rasheed besides the similar from the ilk, have done huge damage by distancing the community from the national stream of assimilation and passing spiteful remarks against the government.
Owing to such misleaders and the utter absence of leadership among Muslims, the community today has been at crossroads and now there is the scare of the backlash of the Hindu community, the way the Muslims, especially their leaders maliciously snide at Modi and the present government. In fact, it has just started as in certain channels, the viewers have started asking questions of the sort, “Why are Muslims anti-India?”, “Why do Muslims want to spread Corona?” or “Why do Muslims hate Hindus?” Such mindset is not going to augur well neither for Hindus nor for Muslims.
The fallout of the Muslim community’s blind support to the Jamat and the anti-government stand on the issues regarding the – surgical strikes, triple talaq, 370, Mandir-Masjid and CAA has been that the ever friendly Hindus, more than 90 per cent of whom, are truly secular and accommodating, have been feeling frustrated on account of this recalcitrant behavior of Muslims. Even after the Supreme Court decision on Mandir-Masjid issue, when an air of amicability was seen between Hindus and Muslims, the AIMPLB (All India Muslim Personal Law Board), the so-called representative body of Muslims, annihilating that air of affability, spited all that by filing the review petition on the unreasonable plea at that time that it is their constitutional right.
In almost all walks of life, including the televised debates, the way most Muslim leaders and representatives set a negative narrative, might result in the non-Muslims completely slamming whatever the opened doors were there. These bigots think that they have the right to dictate terms and espouse views on issues that extend from the public domain of Indian Muslims to the privacy of their bedroom. Stoke a controversy involving the community and the usual suspects start emerging from the murky and infested woodwork of the Muslim platforms. This might tear away in the social and secular fabric of India.
Though there might not be a Hindu backlash, yet the Indian Muslims have left no stone unturned in instigating the otherwise cool Hindu community. The direct example of the fallout of this disastrous situation is that a doctor in Rajasthan refused point blank to treat a terminally pregnant Muslim woman and told the couple to go to Jaipur. Aghast and disgusted, the couple proceeded to Jaipur in an ambulance and on the way, the infant was delivered but died for want of medical treatment. The doctor on duty must not have refused treatment at any cost to a patient discriminating her on the basis of religion.
Yet another example of this has been when two non-Muslim women were standing at a Muslim fruit-seller’s cart selling apples and one of them wanted to buy these. The other advised her not to buy as the vendor might have spitted on them! I view this venomous patterning to be the outcome of the spewing of venom by the so-called Muslim leaders who keep feathering their nests but leave their cajoled and beleaguered blind followers, at the mercy of God. How catastrophic can these things be, remains only to be imagined!
The present Markaz mishap, has already created the social distancing, primarily between Hindus and Muslims and Prime Minister Modi supporters and haters. The unwarranted development smacks of the communalized ambience of 1947 pre and post Partition phase. Though India will not see another vivisection; nevertheless, there’s a parallel ghetto mindset that seems to have percolated among the Indian Muslims who do not want to adhere to the instructions of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
There is a fear that the already beleaguered and cajoled Muslims may be ostracized in Indian society owing to being provoked by these clerics whose positions are safe owing to the material wealth sans all values, amassed by them but their unassuming brainwashed followers might face the backlash.
Nevertheless, the silver lining has been that not the entire Muslim community is like that. Still a fifty per cent has been liberal and balanced, catering to the voice of sanity and reason. The problem has been that this liberal chunk has no courage to come up openly and call a spade a spade. They fear that the belligerent other half will turn their lives hell if they support the government or Modi.
Firoz Bakht Ahmed
In the present scenario of these testing and trying times, one is reminded of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, the doyen of communal harmony and the first Minister of Education of India who was a deeply religious Muslim leader and renowned Islamic theologian but communal harmony was dearest to him. While people were fleeing to Pakistan in 1947, he had stated: Jo chala gaya usey bhool ja/ Hind ko apni jannat bana! (Forget the one who has left/ Let India be your home the best). As the Arabs called India as Dar-ul-Harab (land ruled by non-Muslim), Maulana countered that giving India the title — Dar-ul-Aman (land of peace). True, ours has been a land of mixed traditions. Ex-President of India, Dr Zakir Hussain, who too devoted his life to Jamia Millia, never once mounted a platform to espouse a communal cause, nor did Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed. Today, people of their standing are needed to counter inflammable propaganda. Their very presence and action would keep the majority community in check. Instead, small time leaders have adopted the view that the best defence is offence.
Firoz Bakht Ahmed is a former chancellor of Maulana Azad National Urdu University (MANUU), commentator on educational and social issues, community worker and the grandnephew of Bharat Ratna Maulana Abul Kalam Azad. He lives in Delhi
